Let's Talk Legal: Homeowner Association Documents

January 21, 2025 | Cecil Harvell

Cecil Harvell and Wes Collins discussed the complexities and legal implications of homeowners associations (HOAs) during the meeting, emphasizing the importance of understanding governing documents and the responsibilities of both developers and property owners. They highlighted the need for homeowners to be actively engaged in their associations to ensure proper governance and to protect their rights, especially during transitions from developer control. The speakers also advised potential buyers to thoroughly review HOA documents with legal counsel before purchasing property to avoid future disputes.

Current Issues in HOAs

  • Wes Collins notes an increase in cases related to condo and homeowners associations, highlighting various issues such as asset protection, litigation, and disputes over dues and assessments. [01:00]

Legal Framework Governing HOAs

  • The conversation covers the legal frameworks that govern HOAs, including the North Carolina Condominium Act, the Planned Community Act, and the Non-Profit Corporation Act. The complexity of these laws often confuses property owners. [02:30]

Transition of Control from Developer to HOA

  • The process of transitioning control from developers to homeowner associations is discussed. This includes the responsibilities that fall to property owners once the association is established and the importance of having competent legal counsel during this transition. [05:00]

Importance of Active Participation

  • Cecil Harvell emphasizes the need for homeowners to be actively engaged in their associations. Decisions made by the board can significantly impact all owners, and homeowners should stay informed about these decisions. [08:00]

Annual Meetings and Communication

  • The necessity of annual meetings for associations is highlighted, where homeowners can ask questions and stay updated on issues affecting their community. The board has a responsibility to communicate effectively with homeowners. [10:00]

Amendments to Covenants

  • The discussion includes the process of amending covenants and the potential for disputes if the developer retains significant control. Homeowners may find themselves affected by changes that were not agreed upon initially. [12:00]

Legal Recourse for Homeowners

  • Homeowners have the right to seek legal recourse if they believe the board is acting outside its authority or not in the best interest of the community. This includes the option to file a derivative lawsuit if necessary. [15:00]

Financial Responsibilities and Legal Fees

  • The potential financial burdens on homeowners when contesting decisions made by the board or developer are discussed. The possibility of recovering attorney's fees if the covenants allow for it is also mentioned. [17:00]

Personal Liability of Board Members

  • The personal liability of board members is addressed, noting that they can be held accountable for actions that are unreasonable or egregious. The business judgment rule provides some protection for board members. [19:00]

Importance of Reviewing HOA Documents

  • The speakers stress the importance of reviewing HOA documents before purchasing property within an association. Buyers should seek legal advice to understand the implications of the covenants and any potential issues. [21:00]

Listen Now
Let's Talk Legal: Homeowner Association Documents
Cecil S. Harvell - Elite Lawyer 2024
About the Author
Cecil S. Harvell is AV Martindale-Hubbell Peer Review Rated in the areas of Trusts and Estates, General Practice, and Aged and Aging. Mr. Harvell is a native of Morehead City, North Carolina and was admitted to the Georgia State Bar in 1983 and admitted to the North Carolina State Bar in 1987. Read More

Wesley A. Collins - Super Lawyer 2024
Wesley A. Collins is AV Martindale-Hubbell Peer Review Rated. Wesley A. Collins is a native of Kinston, North Carolina and was admitted to the North Carolina State Bar in 2000. Mr. Collins was admitted to the United States District Court for the Eastern District of North Carolina in 2002. Mr. Collins is also a member of the Million Dollar Advocates Forum. Read More
Let's Talk Legal
See How Our Team Can Help You
GET IN TOUCH